I-CAR GOLD CLASS CERTIFIED

Can I Choose My Own Body Shop in California? Yes

Share it

Can I Choose My Own Body Shop in California? Yes

choose my own body shop California

Can I Choose My Own Body Shop in California? Your Rights After a Collision

After an accident, many drivers hear the same thing from their insurance adjuster: “We’ll send you to one of our preferred shops.” It sounds like the only option, but it isn’t. In California, you decide where your car is repaired. Here’s what the law says, how insurance “preferred” shops work, and how to choose a shop that puts your safety first.

What California Law Says

California Insurance Code Section 758.5 prohibits an insurer from requiring that your car be repaired at a specific shop. That protection covers you whether you’re claiming on your own policy or on the other driver’s policy.

Insurers are allowed to recommend a shop, but only if you ask for a referral, or if they tell you in writing that you have the right to choose your own shop. California insurers must also give policyholders an Auto Body Repair Consumer Bill of Rights, which explains this right.

In plain terms: your insurer can suggest a shop. It cannot make you use it.

What Is a “Preferred” or Direct Repair Program (DRP) Shop?

Many insurers have agreements with certain body shops, called direct repair programs (DRPs). The shop gets a steady flow of customers, and in return it agrees to the insurer’s pricing, processes and paperwork. DRP shops can do excellent work. But it is fair to ask whose priorities come first when the shop’s contract is with the insurance company, not with you.

Common Myths About Choosing a Body Shop

“My claim will be denied if I don’t use their shop.” Coverage doesn’t depend on which registered shop you choose. Your insurer must handle the claim under your policy either way.

“Only their shop has a lifetime warranty.” Many independent shops, including ours, stand behind their work with their own written warranties. Ask any shop to show you its warranty in writing.

“An independent shop will take longer.” Repair time depends on parts availability and the extent of damage, not on whose list a shop is on. A good independent shop works directly with your adjuster.

Does Choosing Your Own Shop Cost More?

No. Under Section 758.5, if you use a shop of your choice, your insurer may not reduce reasonable repair costs based on what its preferred shop would have charged. Disagreements over what is “reasonable” do happen, so choose a shop that documents needed work with manufacturer repair procedures and handles supplements with your adjuster.

How to Choose the Right Body Shop

  1. Check that it’s registered.California body shops must be registered with the Bureau of Automotive Repair (BAR). You can look up any shop on the BAR website.
  2. Ask about repair procedures.Does the shop follow manufacturer (OEM) repair procedures and do pre- and post-repair scans?
  3. Ask about parts.Will the estimate use OEM parts or aftermarket parts? See our guide to OEM vs aftermarket parts.
  4. Ask about ADAS.If your car has cameras or radar for safety features, will the shop handle ADAS calibration?
  5. Get a written estimate.In California, a body shop must give you an itemized written estimate for parts and labor before starting work.
  6. Read recent reviewsand ask about the shop’s written warranty.

How Russ Ward Auto Body Helps With Your Claim

Russ Ward Auto Body has been family-owned in Anaheim since 1958. We work with all major insurance companies, so you can choose us no matter who your insurer is. We’ll inspect your car, write a detailed estimate, talk with your adjuster, and help arrange your rental car. Learn more about our insurance claim help and collision repair services. Not sure what to do first? Read what to do after a car accident in Anaheim.

To get started, tell your insurer you’ve chosen Russ Ward Auto Body, then call (714) 535-3739 or request an estimate. Visit us at 126 W Elm St, Anaheim, or our Estimate & Drop-Off Center at 2744 E Chapman Ave, Orange.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Contact the California Department of Insurance with questions about a specific claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my insurance company make me use their body shop in California?

No. California Insurance Code 758.5 prohibits insurers from requiring that your car be repaired at a specific shop. They may recommend one, but the choice is yours.

Does choosing my own shop cost me more?

No. California law says an insurer may not reduce reasonable repair costs based on what its preferred shop would have charged. A good shop documents why each repair is needed.

Can I switch body shops after my claim has started?

Yes. You can move your car to another shop. Tell your adjuster, and be aware you may owe the first shop for any teardown or storage it has already done.

Does Russ Ward Auto Body work with my insurance company?

We work with all major insurance companies, whether the claim is on your policy or the other driver’s.

What is the Auto Body Repair Consumer Bill of Rights?

It is a notice California insurers must give policyholders. It explains your right to choose a repair shop and how to report concerns to the Bureau of Automotive Repair.

Need expert collision repair you can trust?

Contact us today for a free estimate or help with your claim.

Request a Quote

New Estimate & Drop-Off Center

Now Open in Orange!

Visit our new Russ Ward Auto Body Estimate & Drop-Off Center for quick estimates and easy drop-offs.

New Estimate & Drop-Off Center

Russ Ward Auto Body
Estimate & Drop-Off Center
2744 E. Chapman Ave, Orange, CA 92869

Stop by today for fast, friendly service!
Call Now Button